The Sky That Remembered: Black Holes, Forgotten Voices, and India’s First Dawn of Freedom

 

1. The Rooftop and the Silent Sky

The night was humid yet liberating, filled with an air of restless expectation. The city of Kolkata, once the epicenter of India's freedom struggle, now stood on the threshold of a new dawn. It was August 14th, 1947—the final night of British rule—and a strange silence loomed over the city.

In the distance, the Howrah Bridge stood tall, its steel frame reflecting the flickering oil lamps from boats drifting along the Hooghly River. The air smelled of burning incense, damp earth, and old books, the kind of scent that carried memories. The Maidan, which had witnessed countless protests and marches, was eerily quiet, as if the very ground held its breath for what was to come.

Yet, there was a whisper of revolution in the air. The streets that had once echoed with slogans of independence, the trams that had carried workers and students protesting against the British, were now preparing to witness history. The city, tired yet hopeful, was waiting.

On a modest rooftop, under the vast Bengali sky, a father and son sat together. The father, a schoolteacher in his late 50s, had seen colonial rule, famines, and movements unfold before his eyes. He sipped his tea slowly, gazing at the distant horizon of history. His son, Riju, no more than 14, leaned against the parapet, staring at the sky, trying to count the stars that had watched over Kolkata for centuries.

The boy had heard his grandfather’s stories of the Swadeshi Movement, of Khudiram Bose, of the revolutionaries who had walked these streets, whispering in hushed voices about freedom. Yet tonight felt different. The revolution was over. The war was won. India would be free in just a few hours.

"Baba, are those stars really millions of years old?" the boy finally asked, breaking the silence.

The father chuckled, setting down his cup. "More than millions, Riju. Some of them might not even exist anymore. What you see now is just their light, traveling across time."

The boy frowned. "So we are seeing ghosts of stars?"

The father smiled, nodding. "Yes, in a way. Light takes time to reach us. Just like how history takes time to become a story. By the time we hear about it, the moment has already passed."

Riju thought for a moment. "Then, Baba… what about those who fought for our freedom? What about the people who were forgotten? Do they also become ghosts in history?"

The father sighed, looking at the boy with a deep, knowing gaze.

"That, my son, is why we must remember."

2. The Darkness That Eats Everything

Riju remained silent for a while, his eyes tracing the distant lights that flickered in the dark alleys of Kolkata, where revolutionaries once whispered the language of freedom. Tomorrow, India would be free, but tonight felt strange—like the quiet before a storm, like the moments before a deep, irreversible change.

Breaking the silence, he asked, "Baba, I read about something in my science book today—Black Holes. It says they eat everything. Even light. Is that true?"

His father nodded slowly, sipping the last of his now-lukewarm tea. "Yes, Riju. A black hole is a cosmic trap. Anything that crosses its boundary—stars, planets, even time itself—can never return. It is the most perfect prison in the universe."

The boy frowned, his fingers tracing imaginary patterns on the rough rooftop surface. The idea of something that could erase even light sent a chill down his spine.

"But… Baba, if nothing can escape, what happens to the things that fall inside? Do they just disappear forever?"

His father sighed, gazing at the sky, where the stars seemed eternally trapped in their own silent battle against darkness.

"That, my son, is one of the greatest mysteries in physics. It’s called the Black Hole Information Paradox."

The boy sat up straighter, intrigued.

"Imagine this," the father continued, picking up a piece of Riju’s discarded notebook. "If I tore up your notebook and threw it into a fire, you might think it's gone. But in reality, the ashes, the heat, and the smoke still carry bits of its existence. Even if we can’t reconstruct it, the information is still there—just scattered."

He paused, letting the thought settle in before continuing.

"But in a black hole, things don’t leave any trace. Not a single clue. They vanish—completely. It’s as if the universe swallows them and never tells anyone where they went. And that… that should not be possible."

Riju’s brow furrowed. "Why not?"

The father leaned in slightly, lowering his voice as if he were revealing a secret. "Because the universe follows rules. One of them is that information cannot be truly destroyed. It can be changed, hidden, or transformed—but never erased."

Riju looked up again, this time at the towering darkness of the Kolkata night, where shadows stretched across the old streets. The city had seen so much—famine, revolts, betrayals, sacrifices. How many stories had been swallowed by time?

"So, Baba…" Riju hesitated, forming the question in his mind. "Does that mean the past is never truly lost? Even if we can’t see it?"

His father smiled, placing a hand on his shoulder. "Exactly, Riju. Just like scientists believe that maybe, just maybe, black holes don’t erase information but scramble it so much that we can’t recognize it. That means, one day, if we find the right way to look, we might be able to retrieve what was lost."

He paused, his gaze drifting toward the city below. "And just like that, history also finds a way to return. Some people, some stories, may have been swallowed by time—but they are never truly gone."

Riju swallowed. The weight of his father’s words settled in his chest. Tomorrow, the country would wake up free, but how many names had disappeared into the black hole of history? How many unsung revolutionaries had fought for this moment, only to be forgotten?

"Baba… do you think the people who died for our freedom are also lost? Like things that fall into a black hole?"

The father’s expression turned serious. He turned to the boy and spoke with quiet intensity.

"No, Riju. They are not lost. Just because history has forgotten them doesn’t mean they do not exist. Their sacrifices, their words, their dreams—they are still out there, waiting to be rediscovered."

The boy exhaled, looking at the stars again, imagining them as the silent witnesses of time, of forgotten battles, of unsung heroes.

"Then, Baba… I will remember. I will find their stories. Just like scientists are trying to find what’s hidden inside a black hole."

His father smiled. "And that, my son, is the only way to fight against the darkness that eats everything."

3. The Forgotten Stories of a Nation

Riju’s fingers absentmindedly traced circles on the dusty rooftop floor. The air was thick with humidity, yet it carried an unsettling chill. He looked up at the night sky, feeling small beneath the infinite stretch of stars. He wasn’t sure why, but his father’s words about black holes swallowing information forever left him uneasy.

"Baba, does that mean we lose information forever? That once something falls in, it’s as if it never existed?"

His father leaned back against the parapet, exhaling deeply. The distant sound of a conch shell being blown in some faraway alley mixed with the lingering echoes of a city that refused to sleep.

"That’s the paradox, Riju. Our universe follows rules—nothing should be completely erased. Energy transforms, matter shifts, and information, no matter how hidden, should never truly disappear."

His eyes lingered on the stars above, as if searching for something invisible.

"Yet black holes defy this logic. They take in everything—light, time, knowledge—and seemingly erase it. Scientists like Stephen Hawking believed that maybe black holes don’t destroy information but scramble it beyond recognition. Like a lost history book whose pages have been torn apart and scattered across the wind, impossible to piece back together."

He paused, then turned to his son, his voice dropping into a somber tone.

"And you know, Riju… this reminds me of something else—something much closer to home."

Riju raised an eyebrow, confused. "What do you mean?"

His father’s gaze drifted beyond the city lights, toward the unseen past.

"Tomorrow is our first Independence Day. The British are finally leaving. But do you think we truly remember every story? Every sacrifice?"

Riju frowned, unsure where his father was going with this.

"Think of the great revolutionaries we celebrate—Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, Mahatma Gandhi, Khudiram Bose—but what about those we don’t remember? The nameless men and women who were imprisoned, who died in protests, who were shot in the streets? How many freedom fighters fell into the black hole of history, their names erased simply because no one was there to carry their stories forward?"

The boy shivered. The thought of people vanishing from history, just as stars disappeared into black holes, sent chills down his spine.

"But, Baba… doesn’t that mean we can never get them back? That they are lost forever?"

His father sighed, brushing his fingers along the rim of his tea cup, lost in thought.

"That’s the tragedy, Riju. Some stories may never be found. Just like in a black hole, they may be too deeply buried, too scattered. But…" he looked at his son with quiet intensity, "that doesn’t mean we stop looking."

Riju swallowed hard. The weight of history—the history they were not taught, the history that was erased, the voices that were silenced—felt heavier than it had ever been.

"So… how do we bring them back?" Riju asked, his voice barely above a whisper.

His father smiled sadly. "The same way scientists search for what’s hidden inside a black hole. We keep asking questions. We keep digging. We refuse to let their names be forgotten."

He pointed toward the sky. "You see those stars? Even if they no longer exist, their light still reaches us. Maybe some stories are like that too—waiting to be discovered, waiting for someone to notice their glow before they fade away completely."

Riju sat silently, staring at the sky. He knew then, at that very moment, that he had a duty—not just to understand the mysteries of the universe, but to uncover the forgotten voices of the past.

"Then, Baba… I will remember. I will ask. I will search for the stories lost in time."

The father placed a gentle hand on his son's shoulder. "And that, my son, is how we fight against our own black holes."

4. The Faint Echoes from the Past

The night had grown heavier, the air thick with humidity and the weight of history. Below them, Kolkata stirred in anticipation, its streets whispering the last echoes of British rule, preparing to embrace the dawn of freedom. August 15th, 1947, was only hours away.

Riju sat still, staring at the sky where stars shimmered like distant memories, some long gone, their light still traveling through time. His father’s words lingered in his mind like an unsolved mystery.

"So… Baba, do you think there’s a way to bring back the lost stories? Just like scientists are trying to figure out if information can escape a black hole?"

His father smiled, his eyes reflecting a wisdom that came from years of watching history unfold. "Maybe, Riju. Some scientists believe that black holes aren’t completely silent. That they do, in fact, leak information back into the universe—very, very slowly, over billions of years. They call it Hawking Radiation."

Riju’s brow furrowed. "Hawking Radiation?"

His father nodded. "It’s as if the black hole, before fading away, whispers back the secrets of everything it swallowed—bit by bit, piece by piece. It doesn’t happen all at once, and it’s not easy to decode, but the universe never gives up its stories completely."

He turned to his son and spoke with quiet reverence.

"And just like that, history, too, finds ways to whisper back. In old letters hidden in attics, in forgotten diaries tucked away in the corners of dusty libraries, in the memories of people who still remember but have never been asked."

Riju listened intently, a strange chill running down his spine.

"As long as we tell stories, as long as we keep asking questions, nothing is ever truly lost."

The boy exhaled, his gaze drifting toward the city below. Kolkata—once the beating heart of revolution, once a battlefield of voices—was now waiting for its new dawn. Tomorrow, flags would wave, speeches would be made, and India would celebrate its first morning as a free nation. But what about those who had vanished into the cracks of history?

Riju realized, perhaps for the first time, that the world—much like the universe—was filled with stories that risked being forgotten. Stories that must be found before they faded into silence.

"Then, Baba… I will remember. I will tell stories."

His father smiled, a proud grin spreading across his face.

As the night stretched toward the moment of independence, the stars above shimmered—not as ghosts of the past, but as faint echoes still waiting to be heard.

5. The First Rays of Independence

The night had deepened, wrapping Kolkata in a quiet anticipation. The humid air carried the distant whispers of change—an occasional burst of laughter from the streets below, the rhythmic clanking of tram bells, the hushed murmurs of families gathered in their homes, waiting for midnight.

On the rooftop, Riju and his father sat side by side, looking at the vast night sky. The conversation had faded into silence, but the air between them was thick with thoughts, unspoken yet understood.

From somewhere far away, the first signs of celebration began—a sudden burst of firecrackers, echoing slogans of freedom, the sound of the conch shell, and voices breaking into patriotic songs.

Riju rubbed his sleepy eyes, still staring at the sky. The stars looked different now—brighter, as if they too were waiting for something.

"Baba," he asked, his voice soft with the weight of half-formed thoughts, "do you think light will ever escape from a black hole?"

His father smiled, running a hand through Riju’s hair.

"Maybe, Riju. Maybe one day, scientists will understand black holes enough to decode their secrets. Just like one day, we’ll find every missing piece of our history. Maybe nothing is truly lost—not in space, not in time, not in the hearts of people who remember."

Riju thought for a moment before whispering, "Science and stories… they are not so different, are they?"

His father exhaled slowly, a quiet pride in his eyes.

"No, my son. They both try to bring back what’s lost."

And then, it happened.

The clock struck midnight.

A wave of cheers erupted from the streets below. Fireworks illuminated the night, painting the sky with bursts of orange, gold, and green. The sound of bells from temples, the azaan from mosques, the ringing of church bells, and the beating of dhak drums—it all blended into a single, unified sound.

The first official dawn of an independent India had been born.

Above them, the sky over Kolkata shimmered, as though the universe itself had joined in the celebration—bright as a thousand stars, stars that had not yet fallen into darkness.

Check more on my blogs:

1) https://statisticalmultiversebysohom.blogspot.com/

2) https://ai-statistician-by-sohom.blogspot.com/

The Ancient Dance of Atoms: Feynman and Vaisheshika’s Atomic Vision

 

Introduction: The Hidden Motion Behind Reality

If all scientific knowledge had to be condensed into one sentence, what would it be? Richard Feynman, one of the greatest physicists of the 20th century, believed it would be this:

"All things are made of atoms—little particles that move around in perpetual motion, attracting each other when they are a little distance apart, but repelling upon being squeezed together."

This idea—that everything is composed of tiny, invisible particles constantly in motion—may seem like a product of modern science, but it is not new.

Over 2,500 years ago, Indian philosopher Sage Kanada, the founder of the Vaisheshika school, proposed an almost identical theory. He described anu (atoms) as the fundamental building blocks of nature, moving and interacting to create everything in the universe.

But Kanada didn’t stop there. His atomic theory was not just about matter—it was about the very order of the cosmos, much like the teachings found in the Vedas. In fact, the Rig Veda, Yajur Veda, and Upanishads contain profound references to atomic motion, energy, and balance in nature.

Could it be that modern physics and ancient Indian thought are two sides of the same cosmic truth? Let’s embark on a journey through Feynman’s atomic motion, Kanada’s Vaisheshika philosophy, and the wisdom of the Vedas to explore how these perspectives beautifully align.

Vaisheshika: The Ancient Indian Atomic Theory and the Rig Veda

The Story of Kanada’s Discovery

Long ago, in ancient India, a philosopher named Kanada walked through a bustling marketplace. He picked up a piece of grain and wondered:

"If I break this grain into two, then break it again, and again—will I reach a point where I can break it no further?"

This simple yet profound question led Kanada to propose that all matter is composed of indivisible particles—anu (atoms). He described atoms as:

• Eternal and indestructible – They cannot be created or destroyed.
• Always in motion – Even when objects appear still, their atoms are moving.
• Able to combine – Atoms form dyads (dvyanuka) and triads (tryanuka) to create larger objects.

The Rig Veda’s Insight

The Rig Veda (10.90.4) echoes this concept of tiny, fundamental units forming everything:

"From the imperceptible, the perceptible arose."

This aligns perfectly with modern atomic theory, which states that everything—from the vast galaxies to the tiniest grain of sand—is made of moving atoms.

Feynman described the same truth in his lectures:

"If we look at a drop of water with a powerful enough microscope, we see that it is not still. The water molecules are jiggling and bouncing around in all directions."

Kanada’s atomic insight and the Rig Vedic verses were early attempts to describe what modern physics later confirmed: everything is made of tiny, moving particles.

The Eternal Motion of Atoms: Samkhya and the Principle of Change

Imagine a pot of boiling water on a stove. As heat is applied, bubbles begin to rise, and steam escapes into the air. If instead, we cool the water, it eventually freezes into ice. What is really happening at the atomic level?

Every material object, from the hardest rock to the lightest gas, is made of atoms or molecules in motion. The way these particles move determines whether a substance is a solid, liquid, or gas.

Richard Feynman explains this beautifully using the kinetic theory of gases, which states that the temperature of a substance is directly linked to how fast its atoms move.

This idea—that motion defines reality—is not unique to modern physics. Thousands of years ago, the Samkhya school of Indian philosophy proposed that the entire universe is in continuous motion, governed by an eternal interplay of matter and consciousness.

This can be described mathematically by the kinetic energy equation for atoms:

$$E_k=\frac{3}{2}{k}_{B}T$$

where:

• $E_k$ = The average kinetic energy of an atom or molecule. This tells us how much energy each tiny particle has due to its motion.
• $k_B$ = Boltzmann’s constant $(1.38 \times 10^{-23} J/K)$, which acts as a bridge between temperature and energy.
• $T$ = Temperature (in Kelvin), which represents how hot or cold a system is.

This equation means that:

• Higher temperature ($T$) → More energy ($E_k$) → Faster atomic motion.
• Lower temperature ($T$) → Less energy ($E_k$) → Slower atomic motion.

In a solid (like ice), atoms are packed closely together and vibrate in place but cannot move freely due to strong atomic bonds. At low temperatures, the kinetic energy ($E_k$​) of the atoms is minimal, keeping the structure rigid. 

As heat is applied, the atoms gain energy and transition into a liquid (like water), where they still attract each other but have enough energy to move past one another, allowing the substance to flow and take the shape of its container. 

With further heating, the kinetic energy increases even more, and in the gaseous state (like steam), the atoms gain so much energy that they completely break free from their attractions, moving independently and expanding to fill any available space. 

Thus, the same substance (H₂O) can exist in different states—solid, liquid, or gas—depending on the amount of energy absorbed or released.

Connection with Samkhya Philosophy: The Universe in Motion

The Samkhya school, founded by Sage Kapila, is one of the oldest Indian philosophies. It describes the universe as an eternal interplay between:

1. Prakriti (matter) – The ever-changing, active force of the universe.
2. Purusha (consciousness) – The still, unchanging observer.

This concept perfectly mirrors kinetic theory, where:

• Prakriti (matter) = Atoms in constant motion.
• Purusha (consciousness) = The scientific observer studying this motion.

Samkhya teaches that all physical reality (Prakriti) is in motion, while only pure consciousness (Purusha) is still.

This idea is beautifully expressed in the Yajur Veda (32.8):

"The entire cosmos is in constant movement, forever changing its form."

This Vedic wisdom directly parallels Feynman’s view that:

• Nothing is truly still—even "solid" objects are vibrating at an atomic level.
• The entire universe is in motion, from the smallest atoms to the largest galaxies.

Even modern physics supports this idea: quantum mechanics tells us that particles never stop moving, even at absolute zero (-273.15°C).

Thus, both science and ancient wisdom agree—motion is not an illusion. Motion is the essence of reality.

Why Doesn’t Matter Fall Apart? The Stability of Atoms and the Vedic Order (Rta)

The Stability of Atoms in Modern Physics: Coulomb’s Law

In a world where everything is made of atoms in constant motion, a profound question arises:

If atoms are always moving, why doesn’t the universe collapse into chaos?

Why don’t objects disintegrate into their atomic components? Why do solids, liquids, and gases maintain their form instead of dissolving into randomness?

Richard Feynman provides a simple yet fundamental answer:

"Atoms attract each other when they are a little distance apart, but repel when squeezed together."

This delicate balance of attraction and repulsion ensures that matter holds its shape while still allowing transformations to occur. This principle, though explained through modern physics, has deep parallels in ancient Indian philosophy, particularly in the Rig Vedic concept of Rta (cosmic order) and the Vaisheshika school’s explanation of atomic stability.

Modern physics expresses this using quantum mechanics and electrostatic forces:

$$F = k \frac{q_1 q_2}{r^2}$$

where:

• $k$ = Coulomb’s constant
• $q_1, q_2$= electric charges of the atoms
• $r$ = distance between them

This equation tells us two things:

1. When two opposite charges ($+q$ and $-q$) are present, they attract each other. This is why electrons stay bound to the nucleus of an atom rather than flying off into space.
2. When two like charges ($+q$ and $+q$ or $-q$ and $-q$) are too close together, they repel each other. This prevents atoms from collapsing into a single dense point.

The Rig Veda and the Cosmic Order (Rta)

Long before Coulomb’s law was discovered, the Rig Veda (10.190.1) described a universal principle called Rta (ऋत):

"The universe moves in harmony, bound by laws of attraction and balance."

This Vedic concept of Rta represents the fundamental order and balance that sustains all existence—a principle that governs not just celestial bodies but the behavior of the tiniest particles.

How Rta Explains Atomic Stability

• Just as Coulomb’s law explains why atoms do not collapse, Rta describes how the universe maintains balance.
• Just as forces keep atoms in equilibrium, Rta ensures the cosmos follows natural laws.
• The interaction of forces in modern physics mirrors the eternal balance between creation and destruction in the Vedic worldview.

In simple terms:

Coulomb’s law governs atomic balance, and Rta governs cosmic balance.

They both describe the same fundamental order—one at the microscopic level and the other at the universal scale.

Vaisheshika Philosophy: The Invisible Forces Holding Atoms Together

The Vaisheshika school of philosophy, founded by Sage Kanada, provides another explanation for why matter remains stable. Kanada proposed that atoms are held together by unseen forces called adrishta (अदृष्ट), meaning "invisible energy" or "unmanifest cause."

According to Vaisheshika:

1. Atoms have a natural tendency to attract or repel each other.
2. The unseen forces (adrishta) regulate these interactions, preventing atoms from either clumping together or dispersing into nothingness.
3. These forces are eternal and part of the natural laws of the universe, just like Rta in the Vedas.

Thus, Vaisheshika’s explanation of adrishta (unseen forces) mirrors the scientific explanation of atomic forces in modern physics.

In other words:

Kanada described what Feynman later formalized through physics.

This unseen force, whether called adrishta, Rta, or Coulomb’s force, ensures that the universe remains in a state of ordered stability rather than chaos.

The Universal Dance of Stability and Change

The balance between attraction and repulsion is not just a property of atoms—it is present everywhere in nature.

1. Celestial bodies: The planets orbit the Sun due to the perfect balance of gravitational attraction and centrifugal force.
2. Human relationships: People form bonds through connection (attraction) and maintain individuality through personal space (repulsion).
3. Ecosystems: Nature sustains itself by balancing growth (creation) and decay (destruction), ensuring stability.

This grand cosmic dance of attraction and repulsion—seen in physics, nature, and human existence—is beautifully summarized by the Rig Veda:

"The universe breathes in and out, creating balance in motion and stillness." – Rig Veda (10.129.3)

This means that stability is not the absence of movement—it is the perfect balance of opposing forces.

Thus, Feynman’s physics, Kanada’s Vaisheshika, and the Rig Vedic principle of Rta all tell us the same truth:

"The universe is not random chaos—it is a dance of balance, harmony, and natural order."

Feynman once said:

"Nature does not care what we call it—it just keeps doing it."

And the Rig Veda (10.190.1) tells us:

"The cosmic order is eternal, holding the universe in perfect harmony."

Perhaps, across thousands of years, in different languages and civilizations, we have all been trying to describe the same fundamental truth—that matter, motion, and the cosmos itself are governed by balance, not disorder.

Thus, whether through modern equations or ancient Sanskrit verses, we are all simply uncovering the deep, eternal laws that have always existed.

Your thoughts??😊